VinoCamp Carcassonne: In the land of the heretics

by Tom Fiorina on March 27, 2011

Medieval Carcassonne.

Carcassonne, the medieval fortress strategically positioned between the eastern Languedoc cities of Narbonne, Béziers and Montpelier and Toulouse, was the rear-guard stronghold for the ancient Counts of Toulouse. It also was famous as being a Cathar castle, taken in 1209 during the Albigensian Crusade.

The declared reason for the crusade was to eradicate the Cathars, a Christian religious sect whose beliefs put them at odds with the Roman Catholic Church. But Pope Innocent III’s papal decree permitted the confiscation of lands owned by Cathars and their supporters, and King Phillip took it as the go ahead to bring southwestern France into the French crown.

Funny, he doesn't look like a heretic.

For almost 800 years Carcassonne has experienced nothing more heretical than tourists insisting, against all common gastronomic sense, on ordering cassoulet, an extremely rich, slow-cooked bean stew filled with pork sausage, duck and goose, in the summer. That is, until VinoCamp came to town on March 19 and 20.

VinoCamps are based on a user-generated-conference concept that originated with hacker meetings in Europe. Much of the anarchistic emphasis of these original BarCamps (as the hackers poetically named them) has been retained (even though the format has been used now for everything from public transit discussions to political organizing), and anyone can sign up and suggest a conference-session topic. VinoCamp Carcassonne was, after VinoCamp Paris and VinoCamp Beaune, the third such event in France.The VinoCamps’ intent is to evangelize, energize and bring together bloggers, journalists, programmers, web designers, online wine merchants, winemakers and anyone else at the crossroads of wine and the internet.

The role of host fell to Ryan O’Connell, an irrepressible young American-turned-Languedocian who, along with his parents, is making wine in the Cabardès wine region that surrounds Carcassonne. O’Connell’s Love that Languedoc wine blog, his tweets on Twitter, and his Facebook page, and a self-published book about the region have made him a star in the French internet wine scene. The co-organizers of the event were a wine-tourism-coordinator-turned-social-media-guru named Grégoire Japiot and Miss Vicky, the vivacious daughter of a winemaker who has become a blogging force in her own right, and who also makes wine,

The first session that I attended was about an European Union project called “places2be.” In fairness to the speaker, a German gentleman who said that he was a computer programmer, his limited French would have made it difficult to order a meal in Paris. I can identify with that, having struggled with languages all my life, including my native English (or American English, as I’m often told by people in Europe, especially Brits). A kindly Frenchman jumped in to help with some translations, which allowed us to understand that “places2be” was an initiative to connect rural areas through a website that allows them to share their experiences and ideas. Halfway through the one-hour session it still wasn’t apparent about how this related to wine or winemakers, or why these communities couldn’t just create Facebook pages, so I left. My major takeaway from that session was that obtaining EU funding was way too easy.

VinoCamp participants.

My next session involved a lively discussion between bloggers and journalists. The bloggers were debating about how to make money with their blogs (this question can be answered in two words: Jancis Robinson), and the journalists were hinting, not so subtlety, that the majority of bloggers were not qualified to write about wine.

Ryan O’Connell, like any good host, took a bullet by explaining how his first efforts at blogging were not that successful as he was too focused on his own wines. It wasn’t until he started blogging about issues facing the French wine industry and posting videos about other winemakers that his blog started to take off, he said.

Another American making wine in France, Amy Lillard of La Gramière in the Côtes du Rhône appellation, told us that she started her wine blog seven years ago to write about being a winemaker in France. The only problem, she explained, was that most of the comments were from “50-to-60-year-old wanabee winemaker men.” Which immediately made me understand why, when I say hello to her at conferences or wine salons, she says “hello” back and then sprints away.

This began two years ago when she was participating at an off-site event at Vinexpo, and I, who had been avidly reading about her winemaking exploits for several years, tried to interview her for my blog. In retrospect, it was almost comical the way our cat-and-mouse game played out in a 200-or-so-square-meter exhibition space, I asking the questions, and she ducking off to talk to anyone else she might know in the room. I finally resorted to piecing together my blog story about her with quotes that she had given to others, who, I suppose don’t fit that into the male-wanabe-winemaker category. I, unfortunately, at 55 years of age and in pursuit of some vines of my own, fit this description to a “t.” In fairness to Lillard, it must be difficult being the target of someone’s dream, so I imagine that having people pepper you with questions about making wine in France becomes tiresome after awhile.

Ryan O'Connell enjoying a VinoCamp discussion about blogging.

There were other VinoCamp sessions about wine tourism and online wine sales, and a particularly lively discussion about the proper use of online social media tools besides blogs, like Facebook and Twitter. My comment at that social medial tool session was that 90% of the French winemakers who I try to contact don’t (A) answer emails sent to them (or they don’t even have email addresses), and (B) the vast majority don’t answer their phones or return calls when you leave a message. We will likely have to wait for the next generation of French winemakers to see more online social activity.

Other than the lack of winemakers in attendance, the main problem with VinoCamp Carcassonne was that the big “stars” who had signed up for the event—people like Hervé Bizeul, a former journalist who now has a vineyard in the Roussillon, and whose Clos des fees wines sell in the three-digit euro range, and Evelyne Resnick, author of the book Wine Brands and the blog of the same name—were no-shows.

I must admit that there were a lot of interesting, enthusiastic people in attendance, and I enjoyed meeting new members of the French internet wine community and seeing others who I have met at other events. And the wine tasting that closed the VinoCamp on Sunday, which featured wines made by the Outsiders, a group of winemakers, including the O’Connells, who have settled in the Languedoc area, was excellent.

If I was to offer one bit of advice to organizers of future VinoCamps, it would be to charge a small conference participation fee—say €20, which could go to guaranteeing the participation of a keynote speaker (or speakers), maybe someone like the elusive Mr. Bizeul, who people told me repeatedly was on a plane that was supposed to be landing imminently. This might take away from the counter-culture, heretical Barcamp origins of VinoCamp, but just look at the Cathars: they were eradicated over six centuries ago, and they’re still drawing millions of tourists to Carcassone each year.

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

Iris March 27, 2011 at 22:54

as usual: very interesting story about your experience written in a personal point of view., :-). I finally didn’t come there – no couch available and too tired from pruning, to imagine a night in the car… but it was nice reading the tweets on Saturday afternoon, which showed, that people must have been very absorbed by the discussions so they had no time to spread substantial content during the sessions – except some private jokes and the announcement, that the bottles would be opened soon…

Sorry, that I wasn’t there to help you with my German compatriot, perhaps I could have helped you to understand his message ( it took me some time to understand the title of this conference;-), but you were not the only one to ask himself, what it was all about, as far as I read on other blogs.

Sorry too, that you didn’t succeed in picking Amys attention- I remember Vinexpo and your visit to the blogging winemakers Off… having been “interviewed” by you after that, I could have told her, that being peppered by your questions about winemaking in France leads not only to substantial articles on your blog afterwards, but is a big pleasure, while its happening:-).

As for key-note speakers, well I think there were some on the EWBC in Vienna, after what I read, but I’m not quite sure that I wouldn’t prefer the anarcho-heretical version;-).

Tom Fiorina March 28, 2011 at 07:27

Thanks, Iris, we missed your presence at VinoCamp Carcassone, and I appreciate your comments. I’m scheduled to do a three-month vinification internship this fall with Didier Barral in Lenthéric, so I’ll certainly be able to stop by Domaine Lisson at some point to see you.

Gaelle 22h43 March 28, 2011 at 17:25

Hi Tom !
What about our video ? : p
http://www.22h43.fr/2011/03/28/vinocamp-languedoc-2011-interviews-teaser/
1 Teaser, 4 Interview… This week THE final movie : )
Cheers,
Gaëlle

Tom Fiorina March 29, 2011 at 07:24

Thanks for those nice videos of VinoCamp Carcassonne, Gaëlle.

Wink Lorch March 31, 2011 at 22:20

What a forthright piece, thanks Tom – I like straight-talking and I loved your introduction too! Having planned to be there, only to have plans changed through needing to go back to the UK for a funeral, I appreciated following some of the tweets on the day, and the fact there have been several blog posts (including this one) and videos since the weekend, that sum up what went on.

My conclusion is that all that I missed was wonderful camaraderie and a great networking opportunity. The talks, discussions and the technical side of the event seem to be almost irrelevant, unless you are, of course, ultra-techy. The Outsiders tasting I was fortunate to have experienced in London last year, and the visit to the O’Connells is definitely on the agenda for later in the year.

Tom Fiorina April 3, 2011 at 10:28

Thanks, Wink, I am sorry that you couldn’t make it to VinoCamp Carcassonne, and it’s unfortunate that your unexpected return to the UK was for such a purpose. I cut my journalistic teeth during the “Watergate” era, so I don’t know how to tell it any other way than straight. You’re right about the great camaraderie that was present, and having the chance to discuss our mutual online frustrations and objectives with like-minded folks is a rare event. You definitely have to visit the O’Connells, particularly if Mrs. O’Connell is cooking anything. I asked her to adopt me, but she only laughed. Ryan told me that I wasn’t the first to put this question to her.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

�� �